All of the products shown above are cruelty free.
Dose of Colors, Kat Von D, and Lime Crime are all Vegan options.
Dose of Colors’ “Black Rose” liquid lipstick was a limited edition color. It should be noted that this particular liquid lipstick was actually more streaky than their normal colors they carry.
As for the rest of the liquid lipsticks, Kat Von D’s “Vampira” and Lime Crime’s “Bloodmoon” are the most pigmented and least streaky. Dark reds are usually more difficult to formulate so it’s always harder to find liquid lipsticks that don’t need a second layer.
None the less all of the products shown above are good quality and good alternative to try out.